Who jammed my satellite? Wargaming decisions in a commons nobody owns

13 May 2027
New Horizons Keynote Theatre
The Human advantage and cognitive edge

Almost everything a modern force does depends on services from space, and those services run on things that are shared: radio bands, orbits, relay capacity. The other users of that commons are allies, commercial providers, regulators and lawful competitors, not only enemies. When a service degrades, the people who depend on it usually cannot tell whether the cause is a fault, the weather, a crowded band or a deliberate act, and they have to decide what to commit to before they can know. Classic wargames assume two sides who know who the enemy is. Here there is no single enemy, the cause is itself disputed because each party sees different evidence, and what is being exercised is a judgement under fog, not a manoeuvre. Most simulations also give every player a filtered view of one shared truth, with the filtering done by the screen, so the fog can be seen through. We built a browser-based wargaming workbench in which fog of war is a rule about data: the server sends each cell only what it is entitled to know, with every item labelled known, assessed, reported or inferred, and dated by the turn it came from. Contested outcomes pass through a human umpire who must write down the reason for every ruling, every order carries the player's intent, and the whole game is kept as a replayable record of who knew what and when. Its first scenario, Silent Relay, puts a coalition lunar mission's only relay under stress with four causes live at once, a latent fault, a solar burst, a commercial provider rebalancing its beams and a competitor operating close, and three playing seats with different, legitimate interests. The mechanics are representative and replaceable; the realism is in the structure of the problem: shared resources, coalition caveats, commercial contracts, several live causes and a bill in more than one currency. In rehearsal, about half the umpire's rulings departed from what the models proposed, and the written reasons turned those departures into the most informative moments in the record. The first attended sessions with human players are being run now. The result is a new kind of rehearsal for a new kind of contest: you practise a judgement under fog and keep the evidence of how you made it, so the after-action conversation is about the reasoning and not about who remembers what. The approach is domain-neutral; a maritime contested-transit scenario is next. The session will show the workbench live, from the seat of each player and from the umpire's chair.

Chairperson
Wink Bennett
Wink Bennett, Modeling and Simulation Senior SME - KBR support to the US Dept of the Air Force Chief Modeling and Simulation Office
Speakers
Kira Ryan
Kira Ryan, CTO - UltiSim